CodeTwo Email Signatures 365 vs. Mailtastic

Copilot CodeTwo Email Signatures 365 is ideal for large organizations, regulated industries, and companies leveraging email signatures for marketing. It ensures brand consistency, compliance, and effective marketing through centralized management and dynamic content. However, it may be less suitable for small businesses with the need of purchasing a minimum of 10 licenses. I think there is room to offer a package for smaller businesses with less than 10 users as they can still benefit from the professional display of signatures.

I would recommend it for anyone who bases their initial setup on Microsoft 365 environment as it is the easiest way to manage licences and users. It is intuitive to set up and use, signatures appear instantly, campaign updates are live, and metrics can be nicely reported. There are not so many points that one can complain about in regards to Mailtastic, maybe some OS or platforms have lack of support, but that is it.

Incentivized

• Email design and layout
• Apply different signatures by group or by user or go so far as to change it per recipient
• Dynamic fields to pull user data from AD/AzureAD (phone number, job title, etc.)
• Ability to add non-admins (usually marketing) to help manage the signatures

Incentivized

• Signature Management Organization wide
• Time based campaigns
• Signature data reporting and metrics
• Campaign dashboards
• Device Adaptivity

Incentivized

• Changing font type and color doesn't work as expected when editing multiple lines in the simple editor
• The custom scheduler lacks the option to recurrently schedule yearly events, e.g. the yearly Christmas signature from Dec 15 to Jan 15.
• You can preview a signature with real user data when editing the template, but you cannot preview a signature based on multiple rules combined like a regular signature followed by a marketing banner and then a disclaimer.

Incentivized

• Formatting per email client/mailbox provider
• Wider pricing options or Plans not per user
• Wider MacOS support
• MacOS integration done not via apple mail signatures
• Unified and automatic integration for all Mail app versions (online, mobile, desktop app)

Incentivized

The solution is pretty much set-and-forget. It does what it needs to do, nothing more, nothing less, and it does it very well.

The implementation of the application was very simple. With just a few clicks, the Outlook add-in was rolled out and the first signature was assigned to a test group. From that point on, I was able to familiarize myself with the product very well with my team and get a feel for how we carry out a smooth onboarding. In the meantime, all our employees have switched to CodeTwo Email Signatures 365 and send every single email with the correct signature. Administration is very easy for us. Adding new people to the signature groups works smoothly. We recently changed our entire signature to a new format. Within a few minutes, all our colleagues had the new signature, even without restarting Outlook. The product has shortened our daily support many times over and we are happy to be able to continue using it in the future.

Great tool to use in every aspect. There are apps for PC and Mac OS, extensions for Outlook, online versions support. There are tons of materials and FAQs on how to Mailtastic setup for a platform or environment. It takes off a lot of time from administrator of the product as users can connect themselves to this system.

Incentivized

We have not witnessed any downtime so far ...

There are no performance issues related

No problems but we had a couple of questions about functionality or edge use cases and anytime I contacted CodeTwo Email Signatures 365 support I was absolutely happy with their responses. Very helpful, polite and smart people are working over at CodeTwo Email Signatures 365 support. I would suggest other companies to take note on CodeTwo Email Signatures 365's quality of support and service.

Incentivized

It is important to make sure Active Directory is correctly populated and that content is standardized, eg telephone number formats.

Previously, we had a local signature script that distributed the signatures centrally. This script had to use a complex process to retrieve the HTML templates and fill the placeholders. What's more, the tool only worked for Outlook on Windows - no other operating systems, applications or mobile devices. We also tested other signature software. In terms of simplicity of administration in connection with the price-performance ratio, nothing could keep up with CodeTwo Email Signatures 365.

The product is very reliable :-)

• 100% adoption within the business in less than a week
• Significant feedback from our staff on how professional the styling and format looks and the ease of use
• this will save multiple hours of IT administration effort (in the region of 2 hours per week) for signature management historically due to the centralised nature of the platform now

• More leads and interactions originating from emails
• Tracking email interactions
• Requires upkeep and internal management

Incentivized