TrustRadius: an HG Insights company

SimScale

Score9.6 out of 10

5 Reviews and Ratings

What is SimScale?

SimScale is an engineering simulation platform that aims to revolutionize the way engineers, designers, scientists, and students design products. The SimScale platform is fully cloud-based and is accessible completely via a standard web browser. The easy-to-use interface supports numerous simulation types including Structural Mechanics, Fluid Dynamics, Thermodynamics, and more.

The vendor says that SimScale eliminates many of the hurdles that accompany traditional simulation tools: high installation costs, licensing fees, deployment of high-performance computing hardware, and required updates and maintenance, by harnessing the power of cloud computing. Users always have the latest version of SimScale. Integrating SimScale into your workflow enables you to virtually test and validate preliminary designs instead of relying on costly physical prototyping.

Categories & Use Cases

Media

Thermodynamics: Gearbox Thermal Simulation
Finite Element Analysis (FEA): Gantry Crane Stress Analysis
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD): HVAC Internal Flow Analysis

1 / 3

CFD for small business

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

At Raycore we design and manufacture heavy-duty LED work lights for the construction and mining industry. The lights are designed to be bright and robust. When we started using SimScale it was in an effort to validate current thermal designs and to hone in on the most efficient solution. With SimScale I was able to validate empirical data and then apply those models to other products. We were able to improve the thermal efficiency of the light housing and reduce weight.

Pros

  • User interface is intuitive and straightforward.
  • It is easy to copy design scenarios and iterate through different design approaches.
  • SimScale was fantastic at providing support throughout the design process. At one point they even ran a couple of simulations for me to verify the proper setup before running a series of large runs.
  • They make it affordable to get access to high-end analysis software via subscription that would otherwise be out of reach for a small company.

Cons

  • In certain scenarios, setup information can be dropped from the models. They were working to improve the workflow and once you know the setup routine it was not a big deal but could cause confusion for new users.

Most Important Features

  • Subscription service.
  • Cloud based computing.

Return on Investment

  • I was able to reduce material required on two different products while improving thermal transfer.
  • I was able to digitally prototype a new product without the expense of physical prototyping several physical models.

Alternatives Considered

Autodesk CFD

Other Software Used

Autodesk Inventor, Autodesk Fusion 360, Autodesk Vault

Nonlinear FEA software with a reasonable price tag

Use Cases and Deployment Scope

We use SimScale to extend our FEA capability to include non-linear analysis. When we were evaluating different software what set SimScale apart was the lower capital cost of a subscription cloud-based software. It eliminated the upfront cost of purchasing a more conventional FEA software as well as the hardware to properly run it. We use SimScale for product failure analysis. The products are pushed to the limit and we need to know how the products will act when they are pushed past the elastic region.

Pros

  • Material non-linear analysis.
  • Geometric non-linear analysis.
  • Meshing.

Cons

  • Contact non-linear analysis.
  • Cylindrical based boundary conditions.
  • Automatically generated reporting.

Most Important Features

  • Non-linear FEA.
  • Cloud based.
  • Great support.

Return on Investment

  • It has allowed us to increase our service offering which has lead to additional work.

Alternatives Considered

SOLIDWORKS

Other Software Used

SOLIDWORKS, PTC Mathcad, Microsoft Excel

Go from zero to hero with SimScale's experts

Pros

  • It's an online software so you can use any PC with an internet connection.
  • Select up to 96 cores (this number keeps increasing) to run simulations.
  • Superior collaboration with simulation experts at SimScale.

Cons

  • Learning from tutorials is great, but limiting. The online help is a must.
  • Some simulations take a lot of time, but at least it's not on your PC.
  • Sometimes the software times out due to the server.

Return on Investment

  • We saved approximately $30k using this SaaS.
  • Running on the cloud saved us from buying expensive workstations.
  • Easy to use. We didn't need a CFD expert in-house for training. We now have outsourced the training to SimScale for just the membership cost.

Other Software Used

Siemens Solid Edge, Microsoft Office 365, Google Drive

Powerful, Easy to Use CFD Tool

Pros

  • Amazing support team to help with modeling and troubleshooting
  • Database of example projects is great for gaining ideas on how different scenarios can be modeled within the tool
  • Affordable CFD tool - with computing done in the cloud it allows for complicated modeling to be done without expensive equipment!
  • The browser interface is much more intuitive and faster to learn and use than many other CFD tools. Significantly easier than OpenFOAM, which is its backend.
  • Great training for new users

Cons

  • The computing functionality tops out at 32 cores, which is typically more than enough but has caused some limitations in the most complicated CFD scenarios that I wanted to model.
  • There have been a few pieces of open FOAM functionality (which is SimScale's CFD backend) that haven't yet been migrated into SimScale, so flexibility in modeling is slightly reduced from open FOAM. But this appears to be changing and evolving quickly.
  • The viewer for final analysis is somewhat limited. This is ok because the results can be downloaded and analyzed in full in Paraview, which is fully functional but takes more time than viewing in the browser window.

Return on Investment

  • We've been able to iterate through a large number of designs more quickly than we would have without a CFD simulation, and also compared to the time it would have taken to prepare most other CFD simulations.
  • Affordable price, and it prevented us from needing to invest in expensive computing equipment.
  • Help from the support team also sped up the process of modeling different scenarios!

Alternatives Considered

openfoam and ansys CFD

Other Software Used

MATLAB, Onshape