TrustRadius: an HG Insights company

Save this comparison

Save this comparison

Add Product

Recommended Comparisons

    Overview
    ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price

    OnPay

    Score9.9 out of 10
    N/AOnPay's payroll and HR is designed for people who want to spend more time running their business, and less on back-office tasks. The application aims to enable users to: • Run payroll • Automate taxes • Let employees do more themselves • Simplify HR processes • Offer benefits in any state OnPay is $49 plus $6 per person each month. The monthly fee includes integrations with QuickBooks, Xero, and time-tracking software, as well as all quarterly and year-end…

    $49

    per month +$6 per month, per person

    Paychex

    Score5.1 out of 10
    N/APaychex Flex, of Paychex' Online Payroll Services, is a cloud-based human resource management and payroll platform. Paychex offers core and specialized services, and scales to meet the needs of small businesses, SMBs, and large enterprises.

    $59

    per month/+$4 per employee

    Pricing
    OnPayPaychex
    Editions & Modules
    No answers on this topic
    Paychex Go
    $59
    per month/+$4 per employee
    Paychex Flex Service
    Contact sales team
    Paychex Flex Enterprise
    Contact sales team
    Offerings
    Pricing Offerings
    OnPayPaychex
    Free Trial
    YesNo
    Free/Freemium Version
    NoNo
    Premium Consulting/Integration Services
    NoNo
    Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeRequired
    Additional DetailsFirst month free, then $49 + $6 per employee each month.—
    More Pricing Information
    Community Pulse
    OnPayPaychex
    Considered Both Products
    OnPay
    Chose OnPay
    Overall OnPay was the best bang for my buck. Had a lot to offer and was cheaper than the rest of the people we looked into
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    I've also used 3py Payroll/staffing companies. I found those competitors clunky, slower in support, overly complicated, and overpriced. OnPay has been my favorite experience in Payroll over the past 20 years.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    While different payroll software options cater to various business needs, OnPay's standout features in terms of usability, affordability, accuracy, scalability, and support often place it favorably among businesses seeking a reliable and user-friendly payroll solution.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    I personally did not like Paychex. I found their reporting antiquated, cumbersome, and not easily readable. Reporting is very important to me as it serves as a marketing tool. I can highlight the quality of our services by providing informative and easy-to-read reports. The …
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    The cost is much better.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    I originally selected OnPay because of the initial free months.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    Great value and easy to use without a masters degree in payroll. Great customer service, not having to wait on hold or chat for hours in the hope someone can help you.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    From employee controls, overall pricing, multiple pay runs per month, tax filings, WC services, ease of platform, and customer support, OnPay beats them in spades. I have worked with PayChex and QuickBooks for years. They are expensive and bundle items which increases prices. …
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    ADP run was very slow and clunky. It probably has the ability to do a lot but the actual process of entering payroll was not user-friendly and literally took all Day sometimes. Onboarding with Paychex felt really repetitive and sometimes HR would have to enter information after …
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    The support with OnPay is on a different level. So far, OnPay has delivered all payrolls without any problems. They are easy to use, and the user interface is the best I have seen. There is a lot of customization allowed in OnPay that is not permitted in other applications.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    OnPay is more affordable and has all the same features I need.
    Incentivized
    Chose OnPay
    OnPay is much easier to use and much more cost effective.
    Incentivized
    Paychex Inc.
    No answer on this topic
    Key User Insights
    Would buy again
    98%
    Would buy again
    54 Answers
    No answers on this topic
    Delivers good value for the price
    98%
    Delivers good value for the price
    54 Answers
    No answers on this topic
    Happy with the feature set
    98%
    Happy with the feature set
    54 Answers
    No answers on this topic
    Lived up to sales and marketing promises
    98%
    Lived up to sales and marketing promises
    53 Answers
    No answers on this topic
    Implementation went as expected
    100%
    Implementation went as expected
    54 Answers
    No answers on this topic
    Features
    OnPayPaychex
    Payroll Management
    Comparison of Payroll Management features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    9.9
    50 Ratings
    18% above category average
    Paychex
    9.3
    299 Ratings
    16% above category average
    Pay calculation9.947 Ratings9.7282 Ratings
    Benefit plan administration9.916 Ratings9.1164 Ratings
    Direct deposit files10.045 Ratings9.7281 Ratings
    Salary revision and increment management10.034 Ratings9.3200 Ratings
    Reimbursement management9.821 Ratings9.6111 Ratings
    Off-cycle/On-Demand payment00 Ratings8.4142 Ratings
    Human Resource Management
    Comparison of Human Resource Management features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    7.3
    257 Ratings
    7% below category average
    Employee demographic data00 Ratings7.2206 Ratings
    Employment history00 Ratings9.4230 Ratings
    Job profiles and administration00 Ratings9.1164 Ratings
    Workflow for transfers, promotions, pay raises, etc.00 Ratings8.7161 Ratings
    Organizational charting00 Ratings1.01 Ratings
    Organization and location management00 Ratings9.3146 Ratings
    Compliance data (COBRA, OSHA, etc.)00 Ratings6.4137 Ratings
    Leave and Attendance Management
    Comparison of Leave and Attendance Management features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    8.7
    151 Ratings
    8% above category average
    Approval workflow00 Ratings8.7107 Ratings
    Balance details00 Ratings8.8143 Ratings
    Annual carry-forward and encashment00 Ratings8.6117 Ratings
    Employee Self Service
    Comparison of Employee Self Service features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    8.6
    258 Ratings
    6% above category average
    View and generate pay and benefit information00 Ratings9.1236 Ratings
    Update personal information00 Ratings8.3248 Ratings
    View company policy documentation00 Ratings9.8114 Ratings
    View job history00 Ratings7.3175 Ratings
    Asset Management
    Comparison of Asset Management features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    7.5
    41 Ratings
    7% below category average
    Tracking of all physical assets00 Ratings7.541 Ratings
    HR Reporting
    Comparison of HR Reporting features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    7.0
    169 Ratings
    7% below category average
    Report builder00 Ratings7.9139 Ratings
    Pre-built reports00 Ratings8.0159 Ratings
    Ability to combine HR data with external data00 Ratings5.086 Ratings
    Onboarding
    Comparison of Onboarding features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    6.9
    165 Ratings
    13% below category average
    New hire portal00 Ratings7.4158 Ratings
    Manager tracking tools00 Ratings6.3101 Ratings
    Recruiting / ATS
    Comparison of Recruiting / ATS features of OnPay and Paychex
    Feature
    OnPay
    -
    Ratings
    Paychex
    7.9
    61 Ratings
    2% above category average
    Job Requisition Management00 Ratings7.733 Ratings
    Company Website Posting00 Ratings9.331 Ratings
    Publish to Social Media00 Ratings7.224 Ratings
    Job Search Site Posting00 Ratings7.231 Ratings
    Duplicate Candidate Prevention00 Ratings8.030 Ratings
    Applicant Tracking00 Ratings8.035 Ratings
    Notifications and Alerts00 Ratings8.055 Ratings
    Best Alternatives
    OnPayPaychex
    Small Businesses
    Patriot Payroll
    Score9.7 out of 10
    Zoho People
    Score8.4 out of 10
    Medium-sized Companies
    APS
    Score1.4 out of 10
    Zoho People
    Score8.4 out of 10
    Enterprises
    ADP Streamline Payroll
    Score6.4 out of 10
    PeopleStrong
    Score10 out of 10
    All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
    User Ratings
    OnPayPaychex
    Likelihood to Recommend
    9.9
    (50 ratings)
    5.1
    (309 ratings)
    Likelihood to Renew
    9.1
    (3 ratings)
    9.0
    (42 ratings)
    Usability
    9.2
    (21 ratings)
    8.2
    (251 ratings)
    Availability
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    7.3
    (11 ratings)
    Performance
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    7.3
    (11 ratings)
    Support Rating
    8.8
    (21 ratings)
    7.0
    (256 ratings)
    In-Person Training
    -
    (0 ratings)
    4.5
    (1 ratings)
    Online Training
    -
    (0 ratings)
    8.3
    (4 ratings)
    Implementation Rating
    9.1
    (2 ratings)
    6.5
    (12 ratings)
    Configurability
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    7.4
    (8 ratings)
    Contract Terms and Pricing Model
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    -
    (0 ratings)
    Ease of integration
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    9.1
    (3 ratings)
    Product Scalability
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    9.1
    (11 ratings)
    Vendor post-sale
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    8.9
    (31 ratings)
    Vendor pre-sale
    9.1
    (1 ratings)
    9.2
    (32 ratings)
    User Testimonials
    OnPayPaychex
    Likelihood to Recommend
    OnPay
    I'd say if you had someone who wasn't educated on how Payroll should be setup and function OnPay is less ideal. But even then you've got things so well setup and cost efficient, they could afford to put some focus on training. In my mind I imagine OnPay is the best solution for small to mid, even early large, company Payroll processing. We're a small company so I'm unaware of the options provided to streamline importing of large group payrolls, but that might be an area where the interface could provide challenges.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    For the most part, Paychex Flex is a very good payroll system and is well suited for a small business. Most basic features are simple and user friendly. For businesses that have hourly employees, its timeclock system is a good feature. For businesses that have a large number of employees and more complicated rules and policies, it might not be as appropriate because of the difficulty to set up for these rules and policies
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Pros
    OnPay
    • Communication - From my first call I was so impressed at the level of care and compassion OnPay expressed. I was assigned specific employees who were available in the sign up process to walk me through each step and to answer all my questions. I know some of my questions were probably "stupid" but OnPay never minded answering them and I was always treated with respect.
    • On Boarding - The nightmare I had experienced with a competitor became a dream with OnPay. They said if I would authorize them to sign onto my account they would take care of the sign up process. And they did!!! They also did it correctly. All of the numbers and information was error free. The only information I was required was input was direct deposit bank information.
    • Resolving an Issue - I have only had one issue that needed to be resolved. The person I talked to had to check with another person for an answer but she stayed on the line with me to make sure the problem was resolved. Then I received a follow up email outlining exactly what action they had taken.
    • Ease of using the website - I can find what I am looking for! I like the verification code. And every time I sign on to my account the red heart by our company name makes me smile.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    • It provides a well account of Retirement Plan Account Information.
    • Alerts are sent to email when there is new information to access.
    • Employee access both online and thru app.
    • Paperless options.
    • Easy and quick access to paystubs and tax forms.
    • Easy employee retirement management.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Cons
    OnPay
    • You can add additional additions or benefit items such as a car allowance. The process required me to contact a representative as that wasn't as easy to navigate.
    • The process for handling additional withholdings for pre-payed taxes required support to ensure the calculations were accurate.
    • Process for on-boarding is a little tricky if you don't start the process from the point of hire. You can add various things easily but it reflects differently in terms of completion of an Employee file.
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    • When it comes to audit reports, Paychex Flex could improve on helping clients locate the correct reports for audit purposes more easily
    • When a client receives a discount, it would be helpful if the discount were automatically provided each year, or if the Paychex rep proactively reached out to the client first, versus the client having to call and request that the discount continue.
    • It would be helpful if the invoice was emailed to the client versus the client logging in to access invoices.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Likelihood to Renew
    OnPay
    We have used OnPay for a few years now and we do continue to renew our annual use of OnPay. We are only a small organization and although OnPay provides a lot of additional services that larger organizations might ind useful, OnPay still meets our limited requirements of running bi-weekly payroll and submitting our quarterly state and federal tax documents, and at a price that we still find affordable.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    Overall I like the features that Paychex Flex offers. I am sure that there are other features that I am unaware of, so I am excited to see if there is more that Flex is capable of to make my job easier. The basic features are really user friendly and easy to access. If there ever is an issue customer service is great
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Usability
    OnPay
    OnPay is very easy to use. The computer interface is setup very well. You can quickly add people, enter your Payroll, print reports, etc. If your Payroll doesn't change from pay period to pay period (example, salaried employees) it takes mere seconds to enter in your Payroll.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    Some things could be streamlined. For example, we could do custom options for the "add items" tab which has so many options that we never use. "Medical Pay" could be something that the system remembers for the applicable employees. Salaried employees' salaries should definitely be auto-filled. Overall the system works well but I think it could be improved to be easier to use and read.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Reliability and Availability
    OnPay
    OnPay immediately responds to any of my inquiries.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    We have not experienced any difficulties with unplanned outages. Notifications are always made for outages, and they do not effect normal business operations.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Performance
    OnPay
    No complaints on OnPay's integration with Xero.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    Unless there is lag time within the internet, the Paychex Flex website loads exceptional fast, pages load quickly and reports that I need to print or download load quickly. If I need to create a specialized report, once I complete it I receive an e-mail telling me my report is ready to be downloaded. Changing between web pages is fast as well.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Support Rating
    OnPay
    They have always solved my problems and answered the questions I had. In the earlier years, they were much better and faster but in recent years there appears to be not as much people available so this results in more email requests.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    Our dedicated representative is one of the main reasons we are sticking with Paychex Flex. If it were not for this person, other platforms could provide the same/similar functionality. It is the ability to speak with someone that understands our business and is willing to get questions answered in a timely fashion that keeps us with Paychex Flex.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    In-Person Training
    OnPay
    No answers on this topic
    Paychex Inc.
    We did online training only
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Online Training
    OnPay
    No answers on this topic
    Paychex Inc.
    It was easy to understand and follow along. I do like the informational videos that we can utilize before we opt to call in for customer service support. It has made a difference since sometimes that resolves the issue I may have had and saved myself a phone call to Paychex support.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Implementation Rating
    OnPay
    Easy to implement and easy to convert any other payroll reports to the OnPay system when making the switch
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    Implementation was very smooth. The most cumbersome task was entering the current employees into the system during initial set up, but Paychex staff handled most of that and verified against prior system reports as well as internal reports provided to ensure 100% accuracy.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Alternatives Considered
    OnPay
    OnPay is tremendously less expensive and technically superior to Quickbooks in my opinion. OnPay is less expensive and offered the ease of managing a restaurant payroll that was better in my opinion than When I Work. My experience when evaluating all of the payroll products that I felt the company could afford was that OnPay had a superior staff of professionals who knew their product and could explain how to use it most clearly.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    We still use QB Desktop Pro to maintain a Check Register / Overall Balance for the company, but once having tried QB Payroll Online for about 3 months prior to finding Paychex Flex I can tell you that there's just no comparison. QB online is VERY EXPENSIVE and not so user-friendly. I hated every minute of those 6 payrolls we ran through QB online.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Scalability
    OnPay
    OnPay works.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    I generally do payroll at the office, however I have had to go remote due to internet issues and also had to take payroll on vacation with me. Very easy to log in wherever you are and manage your TAA and payroll
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Return on Investment
    OnPay
    • Massive time savings. Wonderfully easy to use interface.
    • I've loved the Chat feature. It's provided quick clear direction from your staff for me at times when it was needed.
    • I've had very minimal worry about the tax filings and am grateful for that component of your automation.
    • During the recession we experienced as a result of COVID19 I was particularly grateful we were able to have guidance from your team on how we needed to handle ERC credits. We did run into filing issues there, but were able to resolve them in the end.
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    Paychex Inc.
    • I do not believe we have saved anything additionally. The time we've had to spend to get things to hopefully work is sad. This is the reason we've had to turn off all extra "products" of Paychex Flex. Time and Attendance is horrible. Benefits management is horrible. The user experience is horrible.
    • One thing I do not understand is why are updates for states, cities, counties, school districts, etc. not automatically updated? Should we not get a big red flag if we have an employee living/working, being paid in CA, but they aren't set up for CA sick time? If it is required to be on the paycheck stub to show the balance of the sick time, why would we not be notified that we are out of compliance?
    Incentivized
    Read full review
    ScreenShots

    OnPay Screenshots

    Screenshot of full-service payrollScreenshot of multiple pay rates and schedulesScreenshot of employee self-onboarding and org charts, which are built-inScreenshot of an e-signable offer lettersScreenshot of calendars, where PTO is managed and approvedScreenshot of centralized finances, viewed with over 20 reports for analyzing employment-related expenses

    Paychex Screenshots

    Product screenshotProduct screenshotProduct screenshot