Amazon Transcribe vs. Google Cloud Speech-to-Text

Overview
ProductRatingMost Used ByProduct SummaryStarting Price
Amazon Transcribe
Score 7.9 out of 10
N/A
Amazon Transcribe uses a deep learning process called automatic speech recognition (ASR) to convert speech to text quickly and accurately. Amazon Transcribe can be used to transcribe customer service calls, to automate closed captioning and subtitling, and to generate metadata for media assets to create a searchable archive. Amazon Transcribe Medical can be added to provide medical speech to text capabilities to clinical documentation applications.
$0
per second
Google Cloud Speech-to-Text
Score 8.3 out of 10
N/A
Speech-to-Text on Google Cloud is a tool used to convert speech into text using an API powered by Google’s AI technologies. The vendor states users can transcribe content in real time or from stored files; deliver a better user experience in products through voice commands; and, gain insights from customer interactions to improve service.
$0.02
per min
Pricing
Amazon TranscribeGoogle Cloud Speech-to-Text
Editions & Modules
Custom Language Model
$0.0001
per second
Standard Pricing
$0.0004
per second
Automatic Content Redaction
$0.0004
per second
Transcribe Medical
$0.00125
per second
Speech-to-Text V2 API
$0.016
per min
Speech-to-Text V1 API
$0.024
per min
Offerings
Pricing Offerings
Amazon TranscribeGoogle Cloud Speech-to-Text
Free Trial
NoYes
Free/Freemium Version
NoYes
Premium Consulting/Integration Services
NoNo
Entry-level Setup FeeNo setup feeNo setup fee
Additional DetailsSpeech-to-Text V1 API V1 offers data residency for multi region only. Models include short, long, phone call, and video. V1 does not include audit logging. New customers get $300 in free credits and 60 minutes for transcribing and analyzing audio free per month, not charged against your credits. Speech-to-Text V2 API V2 offers data residency for multi and single region. Models include short, long, telephony, video, and Chirp. V2 does include audit logging and support for customer managed encryption keys.
More Pricing Information
Community Pulse
Amazon TranscribeGoogle Cloud Speech-to-Text
Best Alternatives
Amazon TranscribeGoogle Cloud Speech-to-Text
Small Businesses
Dragon Speech Recognition
Dragon Speech Recognition
Score 9.0 out of 10
RingCentral Contact Center
RingCentral Contact Center
Score 8.1 out of 10
Medium-sized Companies
Dovetail
Dovetail
Score 8.3 out of 10
Zoom Contact Center
Zoom Contact Center
Score 8.2 out of 10
Enterprises
Verint Speech and Text Analytics
Verint Speech and Text Analytics
Score 8.4 out of 10
Verint Speech and Text Analytics
Verint Speech and Text Analytics
Score 8.4 out of 10
All AlternativesView all alternativesView all alternatives
User Ratings
Amazon TranscribeGoogle Cloud Speech-to-Text
Likelihood to Recommend
9.4
(0 ratings)
8.0
(0 ratings)
Usability
-
(0 ratings)
8.4
(0 ratings)
User Testimonials
Amazon TranscribeGoogle Cloud Speech-to-Text
Likelihood to Recommend
Amazon Transcribe can be an excellent tool for businesses where being able to convert speech or audio to text, in a searchable and reportable form, would be useful. For a call center (inbound or outbound), the ability to have a rich transcription of each call (and being able to search it for keywords) is an incredibly valuable benefit. For business meetings, being able to turn a 60 or 90-minute call into a readable transcript to search or refresh yourself or others is a very large time saver which will help you work more efficiently. The software does offer many deeper integrations, such as being able to track script usage (for call centers) or interruptions, deviations, etc.. which would be very valuable to a management team and for training purposes.
Read full review
In our real time meetings or webinars where larger audience are expected we have enabled the captions options with Google Cloud Speech-to-Text tool this start transcribing the complete audio conversation in the neat text format. Also while performing the interview process as well we use this tool to make sure that we adhere to certain rules and are being checked by the superior management team to make sure the transcription has required questions being asked on for quality analysis. Also during the customer call we use this tool to make sure two way communication is transcribed and will be later reviewed when there is an escalation by the superior management
Read full review
Pros
  • Content discovery advancements through audio and video contents conversions to texts.
  • Creating notes for meetings has been at ease with this solution.
  • Real-time transcription: sending live audio and videos in response to searchable texts.
Read full review
  • An amazing tool which helps a lot in a meetings.
  • It's an efficient tool for improving efficiency by saving a lot of time typing. It saves at least 40-50% of our time, thus increasing efficiency.
  • Incredible accuracy with multiple accents & multiple language.
  • It takes punctuation into consideration.
Read full review
Cons
  • There is a small learning curve to begin using ALL of the features the software offers. Additional tech support may be required for some integrations, so it's worth looking into if planning to use all of the features they offer.
Read full review
  • The software does occasionally get confused by confusing terminology.
  • Its web-based interface can also feel a tad hard to use compared to more appealing desktop apps.
  • I've experienced the occasional technical issue, though the provider's support team is quick to troubleshoot.
Read full review
Usability
No answers on this topic
The reasoning behind my 10 is that the UI is very intuitive; I didn't require any formal training to use it. Google's speech-to-text is not just a conversion tool; it helps automate mundane tasks, saves time, and has an almost human-like understanding.
Read full review
Alternatives Considered
I use Google Cloud Speech to Text and Amazon Transcribe. What makes Amazon Transcribe better for me is the accuracy of the audio-to-text conversion. I have found out that Amazone Transcribe is better at handling homophones, contractions, abbreviations, and acronyms. Another feature that makes Amazon Transcribe my No. 1 choice is its use of punctuation marks. I can also feed my own list of vocabulary into Amazon Transcribe to help me acquire better results.
Read full review
It delivered high accuracy in accented and noisy environments. Regarding its language support, it offers a variety of languages and dialects. Its's Api's are well-documented and easily integrated with our GCP-based stack. Also, its deployment is fast, and it is cost-effective. And if we talk about its translation, it gives real-time and generic translation with great punctuation. Finally, its speaker diarization makes it a cool and yet powerful tool that helps people.
Read full review
Return on Investment
  • Working in the backend, I would say the most important ROI has been data security through implementation of enterprise-grade technical and physical controls which prevent unauthorized access to our content.
Read full review
  • Automating the transcription process saved time and resources compared to manual transcription.
  • Speech-to-text enabled us to make audio content accessible to a wider audience, including individuals with disabilities.
  • We gained valuable insights into customer preferences, behaviors, and sentiment by analyzing voice data.
Read full review
ScreenShots

Google Cloud Speech-to-Text Screenshots

Screenshot of audio transcription creation -  Using the Speech-to-Text API from within the Cloud Console by creating an audio transcription is done in just a few steps. It can transcribe short, long, and streaming audio.Screenshot of creating subtitles for videos using AI -  Transcriptions with captions and subtitles can be added to existing content or in real time to streaming content. Google's video transcription model can be used for indexing or subtitling video and/or multispeaker content and uses similar machine learning technology as YouTube does for video captioning.Screenshot of adding Speech-to-Text to apps - The video pictures covers how to add AI to an application without extensive machine learning model experience. The pretrained Speech-to-Text API lets users enable AI for applications.Screenshot of Language, speech, text, and translation with Google Cloud API - The pictures displays a section of Google training course, where learners use the Speech-to-Text API to transcribe an audio file into a text file, translate with the Google Cloud Translation API, and create synthetic speech with Natural Language AI.